NewsLocal News


Closing arguments in Mark Sievers trial may start Wednesday

Posted at 7:39 AM, Dec 04, 2019
and last updated 2019-12-04 07:39:27-05

FORT MYERS, Fla. -- Mark Sievers has one last chance to take the stand in his own defense Wednesday. But it could be a risky decision.

And we're also expecting closing arguments from both sides Wednesday.

First, some background for you: the state says Mark Sievers hired Curtis Wright and Jimmy Rodgers to murder his wife, Dr. Teresa Sievers.

Rodgers was convicted of second degree murder last month. He's expected to get 25 years in prison. Wright took a plea deal in the case.

One major moment Tuesday was when the Sievers' estate planning attorney, Monica Lyons, took the stand. She broke down an irrevocable trust she had drafted for Teresa Sievers, funded by a $2.5 million life insurance policy.

Lyons says she drafted the same type of trust for the same amount for Mark Sievers, too. She told the jury she didn't think Mark or Teresa had sufficient life insurance policies, especially Teresa.

"Teresa was one of the most dynamic people I have ever met in my entire life, working and knowing entrepreneurs, and knowing amazing people who do charitable works around the world….she needed more life insurance," said Lyons.

Teresa also had a $300,000 life insurance policy issued in 2000 in her former name, Teresa Cousins. The policy was predated before her marriage to Mark, but Teresa did change that policy so Mark Sievers was the primary beneficiary.

During cross examination, things got tense between the prosecution and Lyons when talking about how the policy was written for distributing the life insurance money.

Prosecutor: "Teresa Sievers irrevocable trust was designed for her spouse, is that correct?"
Lyons: "For her family."
Prosecutor: "It was for the benefit of her spouse primarily, as stated in the trust, and then for her two children, correct…that's the specific wording in the trust, correct?"
Lyons: "There's more to it than just that."
Prosecutor: "So the distribution language is primarily for her spouse, correct?"
Lyons: "That one part...yeah."
Prosecutor: "I have nothing further."

Lyons did say she planned the Sievers estate as Mark and Teresa Sievers asked.

The big question, of course, is will Mark Sievers take the stand in his own defense Wednesday. This has come up several times during the trial, but Wednesday is his last chance to do this.

Lawyers and law experts we've spoken with say overall, taking the stand in your own defense is an incredibly risky move.

But FGCU law professor Pam Seay says in this case, it might be necessary. “Will he be able to make a good presentation of himself on the stand? So far, the jurors have only seen this maniacal, copious note-taker during the trial. Inappropriate laughter. And they’ve heard messages that don’t seem to have an appropriate kind of emotion to them. So yeah, it would be beneficial to them if they could hear him, if they could hear him say ‘I loved my wife, I didn’t want to lose her, I miss her.’”

If Sievers doesn't take the stand, closing arguments will start right away. Those are expected to last around 5 hours.


Tense moments during cross-examination of Curtis Wright

Will Thanksgiving break help or hurt prosecutors in Mark Sievers murder trial?

Friend of Teresa Sievers testifies about finding her dead body at her home

Curtis Wright takes the stand to testify in the Mark Sievers murder trial

Judge concerned about juror falling asleep in Sievers trial

Opening statements begin in Mark Sievers murder trial

Timeline of the Teresa Sievers murder case

Annie Lisa speaks out about the death of her sister, Teresa Sievers

Jury selection begins in the murder trial for Mark Sievers

Remembering murdered Bonita Springs doctor Teresa Sievers

Jury finds Jimmy Rodgers guilty of 2nd Degree Murder

Photos: Teresa Sievers crime scene (Graphic)

Rodgers' guilty verdict could impact Mark Sievers trial

Sievers children caught in the middle of a murder trial

Neighborhood was on edge in eight months before arrest of Mark Sievers

Sievers murder: New audio and video released

Curtis Wright takes the stand in trial of alleged accomplice Jimmy Rodgers