NewsLocal News


State takes different approach in opening statements of Mark Sievers trial

Posted at 7:43 AM, Nov 21, 2019
and last updated 2019-11-21 07:43:49-05

FORT MYERS, Fla. -- When it came to opening statements Wednesday in Mark Sievers’ murder trial, we saw the state try something different than it did during the Jimmy Rodgers trial.

First off, Assistant State Attorney Cynthia Ross delivered opening statements. During Rodgers' trial, it was fellow prosecutor Hamid Hunter.

It also varied in terms of tone and organization. There's a lot of evidence in this case, so Ross broke the evidence down a bit further for the jurors using an analogy.

“Like a puzzle with hundreds of pieces, or maybe a thousand pieces, one piece at a time, one corner put together at a time, two pieces connected. And like a puzzle, the initial pieces placed on the board don’t seem to connect to each other,” said Ross. “You will hear from many witnesses. Each will provide information; some one puzzle piece, some lots of puzzle pieces. You will see many, many photos, phone records, airline records, bank records, life insurance policies, charts, maps, clothing, videos. In the end of all the evidence, the picture on the box will become clear.”

Mark Sievers Trial: Opening statement by the State

The defense went next. Remember, they're trying to prove Mark Sievers is not guilty of orchestrating the murder of his wife, Teresa.

“Mark Sievers’ wife is dead, and he wants to know why, just like everyone else,” said defense attorney Michael Mummert.

Mark Sievers’ attorney said the only "why" is coming from Curtis Wright, the man who already took a plea deal in this case, who admitted to murdering Teresa, and who will testify against Mark during this trial.

The defense attorney made it clear, they will be spending time trying to discredit Curtis Wright's testimony, and say it's unreliable.

He then recalled part of Wright's testimony during Jimmy Rodgers' trial. “Kicks over a dog bowl, sound alerts Teresa, who turns around. Curtis swings that hammer…bang! On the side of the head.”

Mark Sievers appeared to be crying when the defense was recounting Wright's testimony on the murder. He took his glasses off and wiped his eyes.

The defense wrapped up their opening statement talking about their life insurance policies.

"Ultimately, it is our position that Teresa Sievers was worth more alive than dead,” said Mummert. “Ultimately, it's our position Mark Sievers did not conspire with Curtis Wayne Wright and Jimmy Ray Rodgers to murder his wife. And Mark Sievers did not murder his wife."

Mark Sievers Trial: Opening statement by the defense


Opening statements begin in Mark Sievers murder trial

Timeline of the Teresa Sievers murder case

Annie Lisa speaks out about the death of her sister, Teresa Sievers

Jury selection begins in the murder trial for Mark Sievers

Remembering murdered Bonita Springs doctor Teresa Sievers

Jury finds Jimmy Rodgers guilty of 2nd Degree Murder

Photos: Teresa Sievers crime scene (Graphic)

Rodgers' guilty verdict could impact Mark Sievers trial

Sievers children caught in the middle of a murder trial

Neighborhood was on edge in eight months before arrest of Mark Sievers

Sievers murder: New audio and video released

Curtis Wright takes the stand in trial of alleged accomplice Jimmy Rodgers